You are here
Event or Process?: How “the Chamber of Old Father Whitmer” Helps Us Understand Priesthood Restoration
|Event or Process?: How “the Chamber of Old Father Whitmer” Helps Us Understand Priesthood Restoration
|Year of Publication
|MacKay, Michael Hubbard
|BYU Studies Quarterly
|Aaronic Priesthood; Apostles; Baptism; Church Administration; Colesville; Cowdery, Oliver; Gift of the Holy Ghost; James (Son of Zebedee); John the Baptist; John the Beloved; Melchizedek Priesthood; NY; Ordination; Peter (Apostle); Priesthood Keys; Priesthood Ordinances; Priesthood Restoration; Smith, Joseph, Jr.; Whitmer Farm
Recent studies describing the restoration of the priesthood have noted and demonstrated that we have been anachronistically shaping our 1829 restoration narrative around twentieth-century notions that the Melchizedek Priesthood represents a separate “authority” or “power” that is distinctly independent from the body of ordained men (it has become something we hold rather than something we join). Jonathan Stapley argues that by the early twentieth century General Authorities explicitly defined priesthood as “the exclusive authority and power of God,” whereas before then it was used more ecclesiastically. Though Joseph Smith was certainly a restorationist, like many antebellum Americans, scholars have tended to frame his restorationism in terms of how the power or authority of God was restored (emphasizing priesthood as something you hold). For example, we focus on how John the Baptist restored an independent entity called the Aaronic Priesthood and how Peter, James, and John restored the higher companion priesthood called the Melchizedek Priesthood. If Stapley is correct, we have good reason to return to the historical record to discover more precisely what the restoration looked like. Perhaps we have been focusing too narrowly upon two events, when there was in fact a deeper sense of restoration that encompassed a far broader sense of theophany.
Items in the BMC Archive are made publicly available for non-commercial, private use. Inclusion within the BMC Archive does not imply endorsement. Items do not represent the official views of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints or of Book of Mormon Central.
Get the latest updates on Book of Mormon topics and research for free